Today I got fired as a wedding officiant.
Well, not exactly fired. But everyone agreed a new arrangement would be best.
Here's what happened. A month ago I received an e-mail from a couple asking if I might officiate at their wedding. This couple lives out of state, but they want to be married at the bride's family's cabin on Hood Canal. I allowed as to how I could do that if certain conditions were met -- as an Episcopal priest, I'm bound by the canons of the Episcopal church and the rites in the Book of Common Prayer.
In a phone call, I explained that one of the couple must be baptized. The bride said she was baptized and raised Episcopalian, but the groom was raised without a religious upbringing and considers himself non-religious. They met the other requirements of the canons and the Prayer Book.
So far, no problem. Last week they were in our area and they came to the church so we could get to know each other a bit. They're a delightful couple, highly intelligent and very gifted people. I gave them a Book of Common Prayer and we arranged to have a conference call to do the pre-marital work required by canon.
Here's the rub. Today when we talked on the phone, they allowed as to how they've had second thoughts about a wedding using the Book of Common Prayer. The groom felt that the explicitly Christian language of the wedding rite was simply too much. There's a good deal of flexibility in the wedding service, but at the minimum, the bride and groom must say, "In the Name of God, I
(name) take you to be my (wife) (husband)..."
In the Name of God. That's pretty powerful language, and I can understand why the groom balked. If you don't believe in God, how can you stand there and say that? He was being true to his own values.
From my point of view, how could I officiate as an ordained Episcopal priest and allow anything less? We were at an impasse.
Fortunately, the couple was able to call upon a pastor who is an old friend, and being from a different denomination, he was able to be more flexible with the language of the wedding service. So we all agreed that it would be better for them to use their pastor friend.
I'm sorry we had to drop this wedding. I genuinely enjoyed working with this couple and I looked forward to officiating at their wedding. They were very appreciative of my willingness to work with them and very quite graceful about changing our arrangement.
What do you think? Is there any way for a non-religious person to be married with integrity using the Book of Common Prayer? Was I being too rigid? What should an Episcopal priest do?
-